Theophilus W. Lawrence, 1858
William S. F. Mayers, 1858-59
Frank H. Joudon, 1859-64
John Hanna, 1864-67
Elisha Y. Ten Eyck, 1867
Joseph N. T. Levick, 1867-74
Benjamin Betts, 1874-89
Charles Pryer, 1889-1915
John Reilly, Jr., 1915-24
Harrold E. Gillingham, 1924-39
Samuel R. Milbank, 1939-40
Central Hanover Bank and Trust Company, 1940-51
The Hanover Bank, 1951-61
The Manufacturers Hanover Trust Company, 1961-74

John D. Leggett, Jr., 1974-92

Landon Thomas, 1992-98
Jonathan Kagan, 1998-2000
Kenneth Edlow, 2000-04

Roger Siboni, 2004-05

Peter-Arnold Weiss, 2005-present

Anthony Sanataro, 1974-75
John H. Greenfieldt, 1976-83
Orin Joseph, 1983-89
Richard Phillips, 1989-95
Terrance Lindall, 1995-99
Richard Dodd, 1999-2003
Nadav Silberstein, 2003-04

William Hourigan, 2004-present